Personally,
I prefer the Grimm fairy tale, because of its timelessness. Part of the magic
of hearing it is being taken away from your own time and place. The poem,
instead, roots you to the present, because it causes you to think about
references that come up in your everyday life and the present time. The Grimm fairy tale carries you away from
your on world and allows you to dream about anytime you want: past, present or
future. The poem has lost this important feature by talking about specific time
frames and using modern day references. Also, I think the poem loses some of
the beauty of the tale by showcasing the lesson. To me, the less obvious
message in the Grimm tale is preferable because you are able to analyze it on
your own. The Anne Sexton poem has an obvious message: vanity ultimately leads
to destruction. I prefer the Grimm fairy tale to the more modernize Anne Sexton
poem because of its timelessness and subtle message.
There
is one element of the poem that I did like, and that is the ending. In the end,
Sexton narrates that Snow White gazes at herself in the mirror. This is not an
action that the Grimm Snow White ever completes. Sexton believes in a cyclical
version of Snow White, where, in the end, Snow White ends up like her
stepmother. She is vain and therefore will eventually succumb to a jealousy
that feeds evil. The Grimm tale has a happy ending for Snow White, as she
marries the prince and the story ends. Nothing is ever mentioned about her life
afterwards. In Sexton’s version, it shows that Snow White cannot escape any
unhappiness or evil through marriage, because eventually the cycle will repeat
itself and she will become like her evil stepmother.

No comments:
Post a Comment